Gearbikesreview is audience-supported. When you buy through links on this site, we may earn an affiliate commission that we use for site maintenance. Learn more

Blog

BMX Bike Vs Mountain Bike: 8 Major Takeaways to Consider

bmx bike vs mountain bike
Written by Cobie Brown

When local riders of Marin County, California pushed for a bike more suited to the local terrain, Joe Breezer came up with Breezer 1, in 1978. To him goes the credit of being the inventor of the mountain bike. This invention also propelled Tom Richey who started fabricating bike frames for the very successful partnership company, MountainBikes.

BMX bikes, on the other hand, were the brainchild of Scot Alexander Breithaupt, who launched first creation in 1970 out of Long Beach, California. The biggest fan following of BMX bikes are kids.

These two marvelous adaptions of the bicycle opened up a whole new world in recreational bike sport and their popularity over the years has only risen. Let us explore and see what makes these unique bikes tick.

BMX Bike Vs Mountain Bike

  • An MTB Bike

bmx or mountain bike

  • An BMX Bike

bmx vs mountain bike

Both these different styles of bikes are primarily designed to accomplish different goals. The MTB requires to be a tremendous shock absorber, take control over different terrain, often difficult, and for climbing. The BMX calls for the ability to respond to quick speed changes, be superior in strength and demonstrate great mobility. A BMX is for short sprints around a flat track whereas a mountain bike traverses longer distances over rough terrain.

The six areas where the difference between BMX and mountain bike essentially are:

1. The Frame

The construction of the frame for both these designs varies as the demands of each are distinctively different. Throughout its entire longevity, BMX bikes are put through feats of remarkable impact which they must sustain. Taking off from ramps, jumps and leaps make up the life of BMXers. Naturally, activities of this intensity preclude the need for a strong frame. The size of most BMX bikes is similar to a compact frame is a prerequisite.

The demands imposed on MTB bikes are they must be very rugged though the violence quotient required of BMX bikes is less. Vibration absorption and functionality is the governing requirement of the MTB frame. It addresses flexibility and the size depends on that of the rider.

Bestseller No. 1
Huffy Hardtail Mountain Trail Bike 24 inch, 26 inch, 27.5 inch, 26 Inch Wheels/17 Inch Frame, Military Green Gloss
  • Scroll down for an assembly video; attack trails and combat terrain on the mighty Huffy Exxo, a ruthless ride in military green; this exclusive is ideal for ages 13 and up and a minimum rider height of 5 feet
  • The lightweight aluminum hardtail frame is backed by our limited 10-year warranty (see owner's manual for details); Aluminum (much lighter than steel) provides more rolling momentum so it's easier to pedal for speed and acceleration
  • Promptly draw on 21 speeds on-demand for uphill climbing, downhill riding, or pure acceleration with the indexed Shimano TZ-31 rear derailleur and micro-shift twist shifter; suspension fork absorbs bumps for a better ride
  • Knobby 26" X 1.95" tires bite into dirt and gravel paths with ease in wet or dry conditions; alloy linear pull brakes with machined alloy wheel rims provide smooth stopping power; premium padded ATB saddle has stitched sides for quality
  • Slight-rise handlebar enables upright riding to minimize back and shoulder strain; ATB-type resin pedals on the 3-piece crank have responsive feel; Kraton grips remain comfortable to the touch on long rides; kickstand included
Bestseller No. 2
SIRDAR S-900 27 Speed 27.5 inch Mountain Bike Aluminum Alloy and High Carbon Steel with 2 Replaceable Seat, Full Suspension Disc Brake Outdoor Bikes for Men Women
  • 【Full Aluminum Alloy Frame】Aluminum alloy body with high carbon steel parts, such as handle bar, chain. Sturdy materials can prevent bikes from damage, also on rainy days, strong enough to withstand any harsh environment
  • 【27 Speed Professional Mountain Bike】3 gears front derailleur and 9 gears derailleur deliver 27 speeds of ultra smooth shifting, finger-type shifter. The front and rear double disc brakes provide powerful braking and it's not easy to accumulate dust in the brakes
  • 【Excellent Shock Absorbers】27.5x1.95in wide tires with premium aluminum suspension fork to help you smooth over gravel. With 2 replaceable saddle, 1x mountain cross-country saddle, 1x wide soft saddle, suitable for mountain roads and highways.
  • 【95% Assembled】95% of the bike have been assembled, all you need to do is install the front wheels, handlebars, pedal and saddle. Then you can complete a 27.5inch SIRDAR mountain bike and enjoy the ride (Including assembly tools)
  • 【Best Customer Service】SIRDAR has professional customer service. We provide after-sales service for 1 year, during this period, we will give corresponding solutions to your problems and help you solve them

2. Wheels

A BMX would feature 20” to 24” wheels typically. The design of the wheels is geared to enable the bike to withstand the jolts and shocks of tricks and jumps and also function unhindered on smooth surfaces. Internal reinforcement is provided to avoid blowout when landing from a high launch.

MTB wheels are of a standard 26” or 29”, but may vary depending on the size of the rider. They need to be larger than a BMX bike because they need to navigate holes and obstacles typical of a mountain trail. The grooving on the tires too is large and of such a design to afford a good grip on different terrain.

3. Brakes

The calling card of a BMX bike is performing complex stunts and tricks which require the handlebars to be spun in both directions. A special type of braking system is fitted on high-end BMX bikes so that the brake cable and the bar don’t get entwined. The type of brake fitted on a BMX bike is the V type shown below. It is fitted generally only on the rear wheel. The V-brake squeezes the tire slowly slowing it down and bringing it to a halt.

bmx vs mtb

The brakes of an MTB are of such a design that can withstand the high temperature of braking when going downslope. They employ disc brakes (shown below) that can supply greater braking power and also withstand the harsh conditions of rain, extreme heat, slush, etc.mountain bike or bmx

4. Gears

Mountain bikes are as the name suggests made for going up and down mountain slopes. They are provided with gearing for uphill climbs. This means they have a central cog and a rear-wheel cog which shifts the chain to different levels to tackle steep inclines. They can have up to 24 gears to negotiate a wide range of topography.

BMX bikes by nature are for quick sprints with jumps on a flat track and have no real need for traversing steep climbs. They are provided with a single gear system. The pedals are large with a roughened area and flat. Clip-on are provided too. MTB pedals follow the same format and may have an extra strap for the shoe.

5. Suspension

The suspension of a bicycle is the structure adopted to suspend the rider and the bicycle as a means of insulation from terrain or surface irregularities. Bicycle suspension is essentially used on mountain bikes but is also fairly common on hybrid bicycles.

BMX bikes are not provided with any suspension. During the sprint, encountered obstacles are overcome using power and maximal thrust. Any impact is absorbed by their legs and bodies.

An MTB, on the other hand, has either full suspension or as in the hardtail, only front suspension. This translates as greater cushioning for the rider as the tires follow uneven an irregular surfaces.

6. Rides

MTBs present a far smoother ride than BMXs. This is the direct result of the suspension provided whether it is front suspension alone or full. As is often the case, the landscape being negotiated by a mountain bike calls for suspension providing some reprieve to arms, legs, and rear.

Mongoose Legion Mag Freestyle Sidewalk BMX Bike for-Kids,-Children and Beginner-Level to Advanced Riders, 20-inch Wheels, Hi-Ten Steel Frame, Micro Drive 25x9T BMX Gearing, Orange
  • Mongoose Hi-Ten steel BMX frame and fork is sturdy and ready for action
  • Tough machined aluminum mag wheels with sealed bearings gives a look that will turn heads
  • 4 freestyle pegs offer unlimited trick potential, along with a cable detangler for 360 degree handlebar spins
  • Alloy 4 bolt front-load stem clamps bars tight
  • Alloy caliper brake and rear U-brakes for secure stops

BMXers have unfortunately no such fallback and have to allow their bodies to take it, especially the arms and legs. But the more experience you pile on as a BMXer will make your anticipation and expertise that much keener to bring the impacts and jolts to a minimal. As BMX bikes are associated with more health risks, one must choose a BMX bike very carefully.

7. Pros and Cons of BMX Bike

Pros

  • Lightweight
  • Easily transportable
  • Inexpensive
  • Fewer repairs
  • Compatible for concrete
  • Perfect for skate parks

Cons

  • Not designed for distance
  • Uncomfortable
  • Hilly terrain poses a challenge
  • No suspension resulting in a rough ride

8. Pros and Cons of MTB Bike

Pros

  • Uses are diverse
  • Hill negotiation easier as they have gears
  • Smooth ride because of suspension

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Gear system requires maintenance
  • Can be heavy

The Bottom Line

We now have a grasp of the main points of difference between BMX vs MTB and can appreciate that these glaring differences are a result of the use to which is designed for and put to. So if you are in two minds which bike to go in for, after reading our guide, we hope we have been lucid enough to present the two types as pretty distinct. You need to decide carefully. And do not forget to don proper safety gear; helmet, kneepads, shin-pads, and gloves. BMX biking can provide ample scope for bodily harm. Both offer challenges and undoubtedly whatever your choice boils down to, an exhilarating sport awaits. So do it.

About the author

Cobie Brown

Born and grew up in Colorado, I chose to work in the field of what I liked most, biking. I’ve been working as a full time mechanic in the cycling industry for over 13 years. I started BMXing when I was just a 6-year-old kid and got hooked from the very first day. Then I started riding and not a single day went by since then that I didn’t touch my bike.

Leave a Comment